Cali Cream Homemade Ice Cream - Unique Flavors in San Diego

Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Orange Sherbert

Top categories (Ice Cream / Shakes, Malts & Drinks / Sundaes & Specialties / Baked Goods, Cakes & Pies / Coffee)

Nestled in the heart of downtown San Diego, Cali Cream Homemade Ice Cream is a standout ice cream shop that captivates both locals and visitors alike with its bold, inventive flavors and generous portions. At 425 Market St, this gem redefines the ice cream experience, offering a rich variety that goes well beyond the typical vanilla and chocolate fare. From intriguing fruit blends to playful options like the grape Skittles-inspired flavor, each scoop promises a delightful adventure for your taste buds.

The magic of Cali Cream lies in its creamy, luscious texture that strikes the perfect balance—rich but never overwhelmingly sweet. Customers rave about the unique taste profiles, such as a refreshing lavender or the exotic ube and matcha combinations, all of which are expertly crafted to evoke a burst of flavor with every bite. As one happy visitor described, one "flavor" is actually three generous scoops, making even their smallest serving satisfyingly indulgent and a fantastic value.

Not just ice cream purveyors, Cali Cream also tempts guests with an array of shakes, malts, floats, and even hot drinks like hot chocolate floats and aromatic coffees. The indulgent "Scoop Dogg Shakes" stand out as a must-try for anyone craving an over-the-top creamy treat. Behind the counter, the friendly, knowledgeable staff elevate the experience by offering samples, sharing their personal favorites, and creating a fun, welcoming atmosphere that keeps customers coming back—some, as devoted as Vivian Harper, say they had to visit three times during their trip!

The vibe at Cali Cream is casual yet vibrant, buzzing with energy especially after local sports games when the shop fills with enthusiastic patrons. Despite the rush, service remains impressively swift and attentive, reflecting the team’s genuine passion for what they do. The thoughtful menu presentation on laminated sheets mirrors the care put into every aspect of the customer experience.

Whether you’re a San Diego local or just passing through, Cali Cream Homemade Ice Cream offers an unforgettable sweet escape. It’s a place where creativity meets comfort, portions are generous enough to share (or not), and every visit feels like a special treat. If you love ice cream that’s creamy, unique, and crafted with a playful spirit, Cali Cream is a destination with memories you’ll savor long after the last lick.

Contact: 425 Market St, San Diego, CA 92101 | Phone: +1 619-450-4078

Has wheelchair-accessible car park
Has wheelchair-accessible entrance

Offers kerbside pickup
Has no-contact delivery
Offers delivery
In-store pick-up for online orders
Has in-store shopping
On-site services available
Offers takeaway
Serves dine-in
Offers same-day delivery

Good for solo dining

Accepts credit cards
Accepts debit cards
Accepts NFC mobile payments

The Guy

11/12/2025

Stumbling in on a drunk Saturday after the Padres game 8:36pm this place is definitely packed at certain moments staff is quick to get the ice cream out and are very eager to help! The ice cream shop has plenty of flavors and delicious baked goods that all feel a tad more refreshing then on the sweet side and the menus are handed out on laminated sheets to guests but no one picks up on that and give the courtesy of passing them out so their is a tad uptake on figuring out what they have when you finally get to the counter. Ultimately not bad ice cream and plenty of flavors just wouldn’t say it’s the best in San Diego.

Benjamin Brown

29/11/2025

Great ice cream! So many flavors to pick from, from your standard vanilla and chocolate to various coffee flavors, fruits, and even one based on grape Skittles! Walking in I was immediately helped by a friendly dude behind the counter who helped with samples and told me about his favorites, and then another coworker piped in in fun disagreement with her top picks; so I ended up picking one of each of their recommendations, the salted caramel and the Kahlua - the Kahlua was fantastic, got the bite of Kahlua and little bits of crunchy espresso bean throughout. I'm definitely coming back

Lisa

03/11/2025

Stopped in during a trip to San Diego and had a wonderful experience. The staff was friendly and the portions are huge. We got a flight, 4 flavors, brownie, ube/matcha, lavender honeycomb/key lime. Flavors are delicious! The brownies look very sumptuous but didn’t indulge too much! Definitely recommend!

Vaish “Siso” C

27/09/2025

Really creamy and not very sweet! We had lavender and it was delicious! Portion size is huge for one flavor. They go by flavors rather than scoops. One flavor is 3 scoops - the smallest.

Vivian Harper

12/09/2025

I had to go here three times on my five day trip. Amazing ice cream, so many options. Highly recommend the Cookie Monster or something with cheesecake if that’s your thing. So good. I will dream about you Cali Cream.

Rage Thomas

06/09/2025

Delicious ice cream place. The smallest size is still huge. Lots of interesting flavors broken down by the weirdest menu design. The staff was helpful and friendly. The service was quick and overall clean.

Eric Yeeger

03/09/2025

I haven’t had ice cream I enjoy this much in a long time. Tons of great flavors - all very unique. Very creamy consistency. Price seems kinda high at first glance ($6 for smallest size/single flavor), but they give you like 3 scoops of ice cream, it’s ridiculous. So it actually ends up being a great value. 5/5 I would totally go out of my way for this and I will dream of it.

Diana

24/08/2025

Delicious ice cream. Many flavors to pick from and they have some flavors that other ice cream shops don’t have. Definitely will come back for more to taste. Thanks. Yummy

Your insights help other diners decide. We’ll keep your email private. Required fields are marked *